Field Wiring Best Practices for DI Modules
This guide covers best practices for wiring digital inputs on BAS controllers, specifically addressing shared vs individual return wiring.
The Question: Shared Return vs Individual Return
When wiring multiple dry contact inputs (door switches, status contacts, etc.) to a DI module:
Option A: Shared Return
Option B: Individual Returns
Best Practice: Individual Returns
Recommendation: Use individual return wires for each digital input.
Reasons for Individual Returns
| Benefit | Explanation |
|---|
| Easier troubleshooting | Isolate problems to specific circuit |
| Better signal integrity | No shared return path noise |
| Matches field wiring | 18/2 cables have dedicated pair |
| Proper isolation | Each device electrically independent |
| Simpler documentation | 1:1 terminal mapping |
| Reduced crosstalk | Important for sensitive inputs |
When Shared Returns Are Acceptable
Shared returns may be OK when:
- All inputs are on same equipment (e.g., multi-pole relay)
- Very short distances (within same enclosure)
- Common ground is already established
- Controller specifically designed for shared common
Wiring Standards
Typical Field Cable: 18/2 Shielded
For each digital input:
- Red wire: Signal (to input terminal)
- Black wire: Return (to common terminal)
- Shield: Ground at controller end only
Terminal Assignment Example (Individual Returns)
For SpaceLogic DI-16 or similar:
| Field Device | Cable | Signal Terminal | Return Terminal |
|---|
| Door Contact | 18/2 #1 | DI-1 | COM-1 |
| Fan Status | 18/2 #2 | DI-2 | COM-2 |
| Filter DP | 18/2 #3 | DI-3 | COM-3 |
Note: Some controllers have dedicated COM per input; others have grouped COMs. Check controller documentation.
Controller Considerations
Common Types of DI Modules
Type 1: Individual Commons
Best for individual return wiring (1:1 mapping).
Type 2: Grouped Commons
Acceptable, but individual cables still recommended for field runs.
Type 3: Single Common
Shared return required; individual field cables still land at single COM.
SpaceLogic DI-16 Specifics
The Schneider SpaceLogic DI-16 module:
- 16 digital inputs
- Grouped commons (typically 4 inputs per common)
- Still recommended: Individual return wires from field
- At controller: Multiple returns can share grouped COM
Installation Guidelines
Do's
- Do use 18/2 shielded cable for each input
- Do land each return on nearest available COM terminal
- Do label both ends of every wire
- Do maintain consistent color coding (signal = red, return = black)
- Do ground shields at controller end only
Don'ts
- Don't daisy-chain common connections in the field
- Don't use single wire with common return across multiple devices
- Don't mix power supply returns with signal returns
- Don't exceed voltage ratings (typically 24VDC)
Troubleshooting Advantages
With individual returns, troubleshooting is straightforward:
Problem: Single input not reading correctly
With Individual Return:
- Disconnect cable at controller
- Measure continuity/resistance of that cable only
- Verify field device operation
- Repair specific circuit
With Shared Return:
- Multiple inputs may be affected
- Must isolate which device is problematic
- Shared path makes diagnosis harder
- Potential for multiple fault points
Cost Considerations
Argument for shared returns: "Save wire and labor"
Reality check:
- Field devices typically come with 18/2 whips
- Running 18/2 vs adding shared return = minimal difference
- Troubleshooting costs far exceed wiring savings
- One difficult diagnosis = weeks of wiring "savings"
Documentation
Regardless of wiring method chosen:
- As-built drawings showing terminal assignments
- Wire schedules with cable numbers
- Device schedules with point names
- Color code legend for site
Summary
| Approach | Recommendation |
|---|
| Individual returns | Preferred - Better isolation, easier troubleshooting |
| Shared returns | Acceptable only when controller requires it |
| Mixed approach | Avoid - Inconsistent and confusing |